Best Baking Liners for Cookie Sheets

👤This has saved my life, I can't believe it. You can cut it to fit different pans. I put it in a Pyrex to keep it from being washed. I use it in my conventional oven. Easy, easy, easy! It's easy to wash and doesn't hold oil or grease. I used coconut oil and olive oil. There was no grease build up. My baked goods have not been stained from being in the oven. It doesn't hold flavor or smell, no matter what you bake on it. Saving the planet one roll of aluminum at a time.

👤People are melting perler beads into dots. I was on a mission to order the beads. I used a piece of paper. The beads took a long time to melt. The beads did not peel off cleanly when the paper burnt. The paper was on the backs. I ordered some mats. The mats were not as thick as I expected. It worked better than the paper. If I got a good batches that didn't bake long, it worked well. The beads came off the mat. I kept baking the beads while waiting for the centers to close. I took the beads out of the oven after an hour. Let them cool down and peel off the ones that came off. I couldn't peel them off because they were stuck. I had to use force to get them off. I ordered a better quality mat. These are for baking cookies. These are small enough to fit on the pan of the oven. The thickness of the mats is shown in the description. I ordered this set because of that. The mats worked better. No problem removing the dots. I recommend them. I wouldn't use them for baking cookies after using them for melting beads. I was surprised that my first order was so small. If you don't have to melt the beads, they work well.

👤Absolutely wonderful product. I tried first to protect things from the heat in the oven. I had a potholder on the mat that was on the top of my new air fryer because the top gets hot. The other is on top of the microwave to keep it from rattling when the oven is on. I tried it inside the oven and it worked, I was tired of changing out tin foil. Did not get hot. All I had to do was put the grease back in the oven. It's definitely better than foil. The seller included a tie-back in case you want to roll the mats up for storage, which I thought was very thoughtful.

👤Silicone mats that fit the oven tray were what I wanted since I purchased the Air fryer. It's about an inch shorter in the width. The mats for baking cookies have circles imprinted on them and they are easy to clean. The only thing I experienced was a little smoking of the mat when there was no food on it. I don't recommend mats on a pan.

👤These mats are great for baking. It is easy to clean up.

👤I made my first round of french macarons. I used the matts more as a size guide. They are very thick and flexible. I was happy with my purchase. And even more so with my food!

👤I returned the order for a replacement because one of the pads was not coated properly and the mesh was exposed in a small part of the mat. You don't want the fiberglass reinforcement to make it into your food if you check your pads as soon as you get them. The fiberglass is sealed inside the silicone layers, which makes it safe. If the mat is damaged, throw it out. I decided to put them in the oven to see how it works. I put them in the oven at 450. They smoke, which is odd. It looks like the heat bakes the mats. I don't know if this is normal because I have never owned these types of pads. I would guess not. When it's cooked, the fibers under the silicone turn light brown and the silicone starts to brown a bit. The mats are less sticky and don't smoke anymore. I'm not sure why they don't put them in an oven before selling to get rid of the coating that smokes off. It would make the experience more pleasant for customers. The mats are light brown. My guess is that the manufacturers expose them to heat before selling. The price of these is cheap, so that step was not included. I recommend you wash them and bake them, and wash them again before using. They become light brown once you do that, and they work well.

👤I like the way that it comes with a 2 size mat, so I don't need to cut it myself, the mat is good and the price is good. The mat did not get out of shape or curve on the edge after I baked the macaroons.

👤It's perfect for macarons. The only thing I would change is to offer the mats separately.

👤We are a bit of a foodie family. That has gone up during the Pandemic. New recipes and cooking shows are always interests of ours. The more we investigated, the more we were interested in the "Silpat" baking mats. The mats are much cheaper than Silpats. You also get two smaller mats in addition to the two full size mats. These mats are great for all baking uses. They prevent food from burning on the tray. They are easy to clean up even if you are baking on them. I love how good my muffins are when I use them. They're great when roasted on them. We've been using them for a while now. We tend to cook at home when there is a flu. These are good quality mats. These mats are very good. I don't think the Silpat mats would be worth the price upgrade. Maybe for a chef. We are not pro cooks. These mats are very good. Get some.

👤I was able to solve the problem of the smell and taste that people complain about when cooking cookies because I did this. 1.- Take the oven for 30 minutes at 180 C or 350 F and Grease both sides with vegetable oil. 5. Prepare and wash very well.

👤I replaced this pack of liners 3 years ago because of wear. I never put the spatula in the dishwasher. I replaced the lining because it came off the old set. It is reasonable to replace the set after 3 years. It was great for the price. Highly recommended!

👤I have had these for over a year and they are still in perfect condition. I use them for everything from roasting veggies to baking cookies. Sometimes they'll get marked up, but they always come off with a good scrub. As long as you cook it fully, nothing sticks to them. They don't work well for cookies if they have grease on them, so they need to be hand washed.

👤I love these! It is easy to clean. They fit perfectly on a large cookie sheet. I wouldn't put mine in the dish washer, but I would think they'd be fine. All of the cookies I've baked have been great. There is an update! I baked over 50 dozen cookies in one night for a huge bake sale. They are dishwasher safe, and they held up well. There is a Awesome! If you bake with sticky materials, I would recommend these. My pans look new after 50 dozen cookies because it saves a lot of time. If you bake air-sensitive baked goods, I wouldn't recommend it. Get a smooth surface. I have orange ones from Amazon.

👤I would not be without them for non-stick baking and having 3 means more production in less time for less money. These mats are indispensable in other ways. When I want a safe cutting board, I put one on a countertop, table, butcher block, synthetic, or wood, big and thick or small and thin, and lay it on top of one of these mats. No sliding, creeping or slipping on the cutting board! The cutting boards stick to each other. Safety, speed and frustration are gone! I put one on the bottom of a transport box if I have to drive a large baked item or pot or pan of product from one location to another. I have a reliable work surface when I arrive for finishing. You can put a pie pan over the dough and flip it over to eliminate the worry of tearing, which is always a concern when doing GF baking. A breeze to clean. It can be rolled, banded or stacked. A lifesaver in an active home kitchen is a real asset.

👤I've wanted a set of these for a long time. I like how food can easily be removed from them and how nice my baked goods are. They protect my pans from wear and tear, and they've allowed me to cut down/eliminate aluminum foil. I don't like cleaning them, it's a pain. That's not the fault of this product, it's just how it is with silicone mats. I've had success washing them in the dishwasher if you can prop them up just right so they get cleaned and dried from all angles.

👤The paper is nice. It's easy to divide for smaller pans. It is easy to clean up.

👤Yes, does beat using a roll! I love these.

👤I call them cookie sheets, because they are among the best on the market. The surface is easy to clean and works. All at an affordable price. Wow! One for yourself, one for the kids, one for your best friend, and one for the office gift exchange. The cookies, pork chops, French fries, and other items will turn out perfect. All money will be returned from Amazon.

👤I cook three times a day, at least once with the oven, even though I have only had these several weeks. The smallest of the three, Will wrap, is at high heat. They eventually self correct shape and get close to their original shape. They are easy to clean. The rubber handles were not affected by the heat. They feel good in your grip. It's like all things on longevity. It's a buy in the stock market.

👤I have had these for less than a year and they are not shiny. All across the bottom was under the lip. I assume the rust on the bottom is from the scratches on the over racks. The price should not happen. Product details show that they are easy to clean and sturdy, but they are rusting, which is a problem. I would not recommend these pans.

👤I don't understand how this is getting such high stars. I'll assume other consumers have not paid the price to own the real product because these are not genuine Rachel Ray products. I ordered it because I thought it was a great price. I was able to compare the two after I was sick with Covid. The package had an odor that gave me a heads up on the product. I read the reviews and wished I hadn't gone by the overwhelming number of reviews. Don't be fooled... Don't waste your money. The product is genuine. These will never be used.

👤I cooked some frozen pizza and some chocolate chip cookies and they worked fine, but after it came out of the dishwasher, it held water in the edge folds, and that's not treated with the non-stick stuff. When I picked it up, the rust water poured out of the edge fold. I had to clean my dishwasher by hand, so I pulled it out and set it to dry so that the water wouldn't pool up in there.

👤This set is perfect. I use every size of it. I used one of the hand washed and dried ones the same day I received them. I cooked a dinner that did not burn or overcook, and it did not bend or warp in the oven. I washed and dried it after dinner. They are not meant to be washed in the dishwasher. I am going to enjoy these for a long time.

👤I heard a popping sound when I first used the small one. It came out warped. I was cooking at a temperature that was confirmed by the oven temperature. I will immediately send this garbage back because it is within the return window.

👤This pan is great. We want to use it for baking bacon, so I should have ordered a bigger one. I like the rack on it to drain the bacon as it cooks, but I really need a bigger one. It is a nice pan.

👤I bought two for myself and one for my daughter. I use mine for cooking bacon and it is great because the grease drops below and it is like a air fryer.

👤I have used this to cook meat, drain fries and chicken, and bake cookies. Love it.

👤The perfect size for a Texas sheet cake. The pan was easy to clean and store. I'm sure I'll use the baking rack soon, since Thanksgiving is coming up soon. Highly recommended!

👤The design is flawed, so beware. The cheap metal that is wrapped around the pan rusts. The water gets trapped in the dishwasher and the rust starts. The finish is discolored. Garbage materials are not worth $30. Sending it back.

👤This is for making roll cakes. I didn't know how much I needed. I use it for everything that goes into the oven. The cooling rack is a perfect fit for the pan. When I make a lot of cookies, I will have one on the rack and another in the oven.

👤I was worried about the quality when I got them, but I am so happy with the thick pans that I have used over and over again. They are worth the effort to clean.

👤You can see immediately that this is built differently than the stores. Both items are strong enough to support a lot of weight. It's hard to know if it's durable since I just got it. During its first use, there was no damage.

👤A very good product is cheaper than other products. Customer service is excellent.

👤This is similar to America's Test Kitchen top rated baking sheet and wire rack.

👤A nice rack with good build quality. The pan is easy to clean, but the rack is a little hard to clean. The rack sits flush with the pan. I would like the rack to be a little bit smaller so that the pan wouldn't fall out.

👤It's great for chicken wings and roasted vegetables. While cooking without food lying in an oil bath hot air circulates around food. If you want to clean, turn the rack upside down in the baking pan and soak in hot water. Clean the rack in the dishwasher. The baking pan should be washed out with hot soapy water.

👤Se ha estropeado al lavarla. No domino, pero te lo avisa en la caja. No se haga, pero para lavavajillas o avisarlo en varios idiomas haciendo énfasis.

👤I wanted to buy new sheets, mats, and cooling/ cooking racks after initially searching for silicone mats for our cheap baking sheets. I searched and read many reviews of Sheets that warp, lose their form, collect water, rust, and emit strange odors. Poor welds, rust, warp, or are just weak are some of the things that Racks can't support. I lost confidence in the ability to find something reliable on Amazon. New Star Foodservice showed up before I adjusted my search criteria. I decided to proceed with my purchase after reading the reviews. I put these with heavy duty rack from Hamilton Housewares. I rearranged the sheets for our oven to fit in the largest sheet set. My wife and I are happy. We now have these high quality sheets in all of these sizes. So far, so good! We don't see any of the issues reported by other reviewers because everything is clean.

👤There is a chance that you will get all of the parts. It seems that this item only gets the pan or mat. Don't risk it if you love returning items.

👤I needed a pan to fit in my oven. I chose this one because it came with a baking mat, which was something I had seen on Amazon. It fit in my oven. I baked sugar cookies and they came out great. The pan is thick and rolled under tight. This pan is very good. I want to bake 12 cookies at a time, so I'm ordering another one.

👤The pans scratch easily. There are permanent marks on the pan pizza I made, but the finish is okay and the scratches are not rusting, so I can deal with that. I found my silicone mat peeling up large pieces of plastic, some of which stuck to the yams, when I made baked yams the other day. The mats were greasy and hard to clean without using baking soda to absorb and oil that may have fallen on them in the cooking process. I don't know if they got something from detergent and soda. It really doesn't seem like this should have happened, I don't like leaving negative reviews. I bought these because they came with mats that fit them, now I need to pitch those out so I don't get plastic in my food. It's too much to pay for a baking sheet that's okay.

👤I have used these in baking pans for everything from baking and roasting chicken thighs to asparagus and mixed vegetables. I've used them to freeze all of the above, plus things like ripe bananas, which peel right off without sticking, as a way to vacuum seal for long term storage. When chicken is roasted with a sauce and then frozen on a pan, the clean up is no harder than it would be if it was cooked. If you feel lazy and don't want to exert that much effort, they are dishwasher safe for top rack cleaning.

👤Wow! I am very impressed with this pan. It is a very sturdy pan and with the silicone mat, this is a steal of a deal for the super low price. It works perfectly with my Breville Smart Oven Plus Countertop Convection Oven. I bought this set and I am very happy with it. It arrived in two days. Thank you very much!

👤I am very happy with my purchase. I thought I would try SmarTake because the package had 200 sheets, which was more than most of the other choices. The packaging is one of the best features. The box is strong. Don't just get into it. The first photo shows where to cut to open the package, but the second photo shows where to cut. The stack of papers is wrapped in white paper. Pull out the wrapped white inner package and tear around just the top few inches of the white paper to expose the sheets shown in the photos. You can pull them out one by one. I keep my rolling pin in the drawer. I have baked biscuits before. The sheets are an exact fit for my half sheet pan and can be folded and torn in half to fit a quarter sheet pan. I don't think I'd reuse the sheets I baked. The biscuits were very flaky. I should be able to reuse sheets once for cookies baked at 350F.

👤I decided to pay a premium for this pre-cut paper because I was looking forward to a good parchment paper after reading all the reviews. The paper was in the oven. I used a frozen pastry from Trader joes. The pastry bottom was burnt when my smoke alarms went off. I will return this if this happens again. Attempted to bake some crackers at 350 degrees. Within 10 minutes, it was burnt again.

👤I waited 50 years to buy sheets of paper. It is easy to pull out one sheet at a time from a shipping box that is easily converted into a flat container. It fits on a half sheet pan with no trimming and no excess paper. I have used it for everything from baking to freezing. I carefully compared the available products and chose this one. The paper was priced less than the role paper I had been using. I wouldn't reuse a sheet for this product.

👤I found the paper to have superior grease blocking qualities, and it was not hot for more than 30 minutes. It is not easy to fold for cutting.

👤These sheets are handy to me. I put the package against the wall on the counter behind the pitcher and could easily grab it when I needed it. I use one every time I throw something on a cookie sheet because I think the package of two hundred may last me years. It makes clean-up easier. An investment of less than twenty bucks is a great investment. I have included a photo after buying more. I just lean them against the wall next to the coffee maker, out of the way, and they are easy to access. The price is very useful.

👤The 1/2 size cookie sheets were perfect for me. It's easy to clean and I can cook a dozen cookies on it.

👤It's a great thing to have, use it for everything, mixing biscuit dough, rolling cookies, and a lot less clean up.

👤This product is advertised as heat resistant up to 450, but the package says up to 400. See the pictures.

👤I think I have cracked the code. It was so confusing that it did not help clarify it. I couldn't tell what I was buying. I can now say with some confidence that 2.5 1/2 means 2 half sheets and 1 quarter sheet, while 1/3 means 3 quarter sized sheets. I used the quarter sheets in my solar oven and they fit perfectly on the rack that came with it. There is no more parchment paper. Thank you so much.

👤I used them twice over the weekend to prepare food for my son's birthday party. I made chocolate swirls on them. The 2nd experience was not the same as the first. I baked the rolls for the party. I noticed an odd odor when I sat at the table. The rolls were the source of the smell. They also tasted like it. The baking sheets had the same smell. They were cleaned prior to use. Unless you want a ruined birthday meal, I wouldn't recommend it. The rolls didn't stick to the mat on the upside.

👤The idea is great but the product is disappointing. I used my sheet for the first time tonight and it left a waffle pattern on the baking sheet and the mat melted a little to the pan, leaving plastic that had to be scrapped off.

👤I thought the title was misleading and I was ordering two half sheets. I got a half sheet and a quarter sheet. The Silicone Baking Mat Sheet Set is not what we received. The description says that the product is made from professional food grade silicone with a fibre glass core and is sized to fit all standard half sheets and quarter sheets.

👤They work well to prevent food from sticking to pans. Customer service was great, they responded to my confusion on cleaning. Baking soda and lemon juice can be used to remove excess oil or grease. Using a good grease cutting dish soap and wearing gloves will help. I haven't tried alcohol, but I read about it. It wouldn't hurt to use the vodka as a cleaning agent. I prefer using these mats instead of using a lot of foil and paper. I'm not opposed to saving money by not buying those things. My comment was edited since I learned that this is common for all Silicon mats. Their non stick function is unaffected by their appearance. I did not know about this before posting the original review. Please ignore this earlier comment, it is a type of criticism. This is what happens with any mat, so I am leaving a comment so that others won't consider it an issue. With limited use, they are getting some brown stains that I have been unable to clean off. Since this appears to be an issue not mentioned by others, I might have not gotten all the oil/grease off and baked it on the mat which could be causing brown stains. I read that boiling them in water will help remove oil and grease. I have learned that this is normal and that others don't mention it. There seems to be a general consensus that heat is important to thoroughly remove oil/grease. These are an indispensable kitchen helpers because of their effectiveness, environmentalfriendliness and money saving.

👤These mats are great. My wife and I started using Silpat mats a long time ago. At the time, they were the only thing on the market and they worked well. Competition entered the marketplace after cooks discovered the usefulness of the baking mats. We needed to replace our Silpat mats. We decided to try this brand after doing some online shopping. A great decision! We read reviews of similar brands. Some people had concerns about the smells or the painted trim rubbing off. Don't you like food neurotics? We have never experienced any of these issues with our use of both brands of mats. We wash them, dry them, and put them away for the next use. These baking mats work for us all the time. The brand of silicone mat performs the same as the former Silpat mats at about 1/3 the cost. You'll be happy to check them out for yourself.

👤I thought 2x12sheets small, but also a 8x10 for the oven. I washed the products and tried them in the traditional oven, but they started smoking minutes after the oven was done. The smell is very bad. I don't believe anyone wants to wash walls and windows regardless of my disability.

👤I was excited to get them. They are too floppy to use without a cookie sheet. It takes 15 minutes to bake in my Teflon pan, 45 in these. Everything is stuck so bad that I try to get them out. I have a quarter of my food. I spent 20 minutes trying to clean them. The food was stuck after we soaked them for two days. They have not come clean.

👤I used these to bake some sticky caramel cookies that were supposed to be baked on a lightly greased cookie sheet. The cookies came off easily after being baked for 17 minutes at 350 degrees, and I didn't have to clean them up. They keep their shape so you can store them rolled up and they will return to flat when you need them. I used a pair of scissors to trim off 1/2 of my cookie sheets, which was very easy to do, and did not affect the performance or stability of the mat. I would recommend washing the cut edge after trimming.

👤I had a similar mat that I got from the same store and it lasted a long time. I looked at new options and knew I wanted a couple big ones and a small one and this was the lowest cost set of those on Amazon. It was a good choice and although there is no way of knowing if it will last as long as the one from Aldi, it is fine and the quality is similar to my old one. I don't know how durable these things are, but they are one of the greatest kitchen conveniences and save your pans.

👤They are easy to clean and heat resistant. Don't use a sharp knife to cut them. The mats will cut. My bad. I'd been using my small mat in my oven and I loved how it worked. I wanted to see how mats worked for cookies. I used a metal cookie sheet, but instead of using a dry pan, I put a silicone mat on each cookie sheet to load it up with cookie doughs. They were easy to move off the mats and onto the cooling rack. I am very happy with my purchase and will definitely order again, if it becomes necessary, since this was a replacement product and an upgrade to a larger size. I will not be careless next time.

👤These are substandard products according to others. After using 350 for making English muffins, both of mine have become useless. The last batches stuck badly, and the silicone appears to have been transferred to the high-end baking pans. Attached are photos. These mats were only used for a short time before they deteriorated and ruined a baking project.

👤Terrible. Terrible. Terrible. First time used. They smoked me out of the kitchen and ruined a bunch of cookies. Even at 350. Don't buy because there is a quality control problem.

👤The baking mats are great. The quality is excellent and the price is good. I use them for everything in the oven. You name it, it's from oven pizzas. I love that they help protect my baking sheets by helping food slide off the non stick surface. It is also very convenient to just wipe them clean or put them in the top shelf of the dishwasher. You can cut off 1/3 of the paper towel roll to use as a holder, and just roll up the mats and slip inside the ring for easy storage of the mats in a drawer. I highly recommend them. We use these mats almost daily and I have had them for almost a year. They look brand new. I have not had any issues with mats becoming worn or staining. I use them to cook most items at up to 450 degrees but have not had any issues with them so far. I drape them over my cups in the top rack of the dishwasher and then when dry roll them up and slip a napkin ring or rings cut from and empty paper towel roll into a drawer so they fit easily into a drawer. These things are fantastic and have paid for themselves many times over in the superior non stick surface, ease of clean up and the cost of parchment paper and or aluminum foil I used prior to discovering them.

👤I spoke with an Amazon customer service representative and was told that they would escalate the issue to have it addressed and possibly amend the product review. I am surprised that they didn't offer a refund on the product, but I think the most important thing is to see if they address the fire and safety issue at its root. There is an update on 11/11/18. One reviewer stated that these are not good for use above 400 degrees F. The mat was smoking when I opened the oven after putting it in the oven. This was the mat itself, no oils or anything applied to it. I changed my review to one star and will be requesting a refund from Amazon. This is a danger. I've been trying to reduce my carbon footprint so I was looking for an eco-friendly alternative to aluminum foil to line my baking sheets. The mats were the ticket. They fit perfectly on my baking trays. These are even better than aluminum foil because I don't have to use oil to make them non-stick! I can cook even better. I will recommend this to my friends.