Best Baking Sheets for Oven Nonstick

👤These sheets are not of good quality. After the first wash in the dishwasher, rust and water leaked from under the rolled rim. The oven was at 350 degrees. I wouldn't buy these again.

👤I got some sheets yesterday. They are warping at 350 degrees if you put them in the oven today. It is said that specificity prevents warping. I only used them one time and they are already warped. The product was bad.

👤They look beautiful, but don't let the ratings fool you. I bought these last week to have a better sheet. It says that it is good to 450 degrees, heavy duty steel and resistant to warping. I used one of the sheets for the first time today. It was effective on the first use, not even at 450. That is ridiculous. I was very disappointed in the quality of the baking sheet.

👤This product is frightening. If you disturb the food you are cooking the painted coating on it will get scratched. Will be throwing it away. The metal is susceptible to rust once the painted coating is gone. They are the right size for my oven.

👤We were happy when we received the Baking sheets. They were the perfect size for the Ninja Air Fry Oven. It was very sturdy. We air fried it at 400 degrees. We heard a pop in the oven. We tried to clean it after the cooking was done. The mess was not wiped off, washed off, or soaked off. We are sending them back after giving up. So disappointed.

👤Kinda disappointed. I was excited to get this pan in and first time I put a pizza on it in the oven, it popped and was warped, and the pink coat was mostly gone. It seems like quality is poor.

👤I thought these were larger than they were. When the oven is only on 350 it will warp the pan and it won't lay flat on the rack, but I smell a strong chemical smell when they are in the oven. It will flatten out when I take it out. Not sure about these.

👤I bought these pans because they were large. The size of your vessel is the most important factor in cooking for two. I was very excited. The pans are discolored. I use foil on the bottom and I know they're clean. I'm not picky about the discoloration. The pans pop in an oven of 400 degrees. They return their shape as they cool down. I find that odd because of the advertising that says they don't warp. The size is perfect and we have enjoyed several sides of roasted veggies.

👤When you unwrapped them, they gave me an impression of high quality look and feel. I can bake many cookies at the same time with the 3 pans in the set. They are non-stick. I've baked a variety of cookies with them, including sticky oatmeal cookies that don't have oil or paper in the pan. I would definitely recommend them.

👤The seller gave me a prompt refund. They also sent me a replacement set of baking pans that do not warp. My originals were from a bad batches. This is a good company to deal with. The pans are heavy and sturdy, which makes them good for basin baking sheets. The pans warp very badly when they are heated in a hot oven. I don't find this warping satisfactory. The coating on the hard implement comes off with a feather-touch. Be aware. These heavy baking sheets will work for you if you don't mind the negatives.

👤I admit that I had a bad experience, but the vendor went far beyond my expectations. I was offered a refund after seeing my review. A replacement was also provided. The entire interchange was very friendly and courteous. When the two pans were used as one pan, the label/advertising paper was impossible to remove. We were forced to throw away the pan after a lot of effort. I can accept responsibility for allowing the paper to remain on the lower pan as we cooked on the other - again, it was not realized they were stacked together. It has been equally frustrating to use the other pan. Anything we have baked on the pan has either been stuck or can't be cleaned, regardless of the use of non-stick spray. The second pan is only used away from the trash can.

👤The cookie sheets are made of steel and have a non-stick coating. They are large enough to make a lot of cookies without having to cool and wash the trays. I bought the 2 pack to replace the pans that have never looked clean. The sheets were cleaned quickly and easily. I use a plastic spatula to make cookies. I have washed the pans and expect them to last a long time. These cookie sheets are recommended by me.

👤I am surprised because I am not able to get two cookie sheets side by side on one rack. Never had that problem before. It takes a little while to close the door because of the lip on both ends. I use them in two racks but can't make 4 sheets at a time like I've always been able to. The standard oven never had this problem. I didn't think to measure.

👤It is a great pan, but it warps my second time using it. I think it is more user error because it warns you not to use over 450 heat. The veggies were on the top rack in less than 5 seconds. It was over 450 degrees, but I can't cook on this pan.

👤The set looks good. The material is not as heavy as I thought. I am a metal worker and a little more weight would have made me think about quality more. It is not necessary for what the product will be used for. My kids and I made Martha White muffins for the first time. You know what I mean, just add milk muffins. They came out well. I lifted them out with a spoon after letting them cook a little. There are permanent scratches to the muffin holes. I was surprised. The dish I have in my kitchen is the most delicate of all the dishes I have. I can see rust from the scratches. I'm not happy. The only decent thing about them is the coating on them. The metal brake was used to make the pieces. Don't waste your money on these. It might as well be a Walmart-special.

👤The first use of these bad boys was awesome. After we finished our meal, I melted all the cheese and goodies on the pans, and it all fell off. It took 2 seconds to clean under the water. They impressed my wife and me. Fast forward a few weeks and they are starting to oxidize. Lots of scrubbing. My wow period with them came to a screeching halt. You feel like you are going to bend them when you clean them, and if you were not careful, you would.

👤I bought these for my mother who is a pizza maker. She loved them and was very impressed. She was amazed by the quality of the pans. They feel heavy because they are made of carbon STEEL and not cheap material that you see at department stores. The red handles prevent you from getting burnt. These pans have been used to make pizza, loaf cake, and other items. They are easy to clean up. This is a great deal for the price and quality.

👤I was expecting a full set of baking pans, but they are not even a full size. The rubber grips won't prevent your hands from getting burnt. I used a hand towel three times to remove the pan because I couldn't find my oven mitt. They bend easily because they are so thin.

👤Poor shipping method. This junk is going back. I thought this was an American made product and not the garbage from China on the box.

👤I washed my food after I made a bunch of enchiladas in one of these pans. No worry about scrubbing hard to remove grease. It's easy to clean and light weight. With the weight they lack, they don't give up in quality. Saving space is a concern for me as well, and they stack perfectly together. The red plastic grips are easy to clean. I can retire my old pans with confidence because of my new set.

👤trays warp when you cook, it's very easy to stain any food you cook. The product is not recommendable as the options work better than this set. I have only had this set for a short time and it is so bad that I am going to throw it out. Don't waste your money.

👤You can confirm this with other reviews as well: After a few minutes, the pan will pop loudly in the oven, and the pan will have bent out of shape, and you can either slide it out of the oven rack or make the content of it. When it cools, it will flatten back out straight. It happens on every use. The non-stick lasts 5 total uses and washes at the very most before it starts to rust. I wouldn't recommend it even for the price. Unless you want a disposable sheet.

👤The pan warps as soon as you put it in the oven, even at temperatures as low as 350. It throws oil over the oven. It's seriously. You only have one job. It's important to be safe in the oven.

👤This pan is great for $5. I needed a pan and didn't feel like going to the store so I added this pan to my order. I was not expecting much for $5. I am impressed! The pan works well in the few times I have used it, it cleans easily, and the sticker says it has a lifetime warranty, which is great for a cheap pan. You will have to pay more for a high quality pan that is going to last a long time. It does the job well if you just need a pan to get to you quickly. I am impressed with the quality for the price. If this review helped at all, please click helpful. Thank you!

👤I have used this pan 15 times. I make cookies, fish sticks, and chicken tenders on it. So far, so good. I have used it up to 475* F and there has been no distortion or anything. I am happy with the purchase. I'll come back and change this review when it becomes discolored or changes its appearance. I bought this and I am happy with it.

👤After using to broil, the warped in the oven.

👤I bought several of the good cook baking sheets in different sizes after reading the reviews. They are made from a heavy material which makes it easy to clean up any type of food. The first time I used it in an oven at or above 400, the half sheet warped. The smaller size is a favorite for any use.

👤The cookie sheet was out of shape at the end of the 30 minutes we needed to use it for after it had been inside the oven for 4-5 minutes. It went back into shape, but I fear it will eventually break and that shouldn't happen. Go to Walmart and I won't waste your money. I am going to rip my $6.56.

👤I like the cookie sheet. The metal allowed my cookies to bake without being burned at the bottom, even though I was expecting something thin. It is great for single serve meals. It is also great for cooking in the oven.

👤El producto tiene un excelente acabado y el material es adecuado.

👤One pan in the set bubbled on the second use. I got a replacement set after returning the set. Pan's finish bubbled on the first use of the replacement set. I never used either pan above 350 degrees, which is below the max temp shown in the instructions for use. There is something wrong with the pans. I wash my cooking pans in hand, never use scratchy pads or the dishwasher, and always use at or below recommended temperatures. Before they sell more of these, Chicago Metallic needs to know what's going wrong in the manufacturing process.

👤I have had these for over a month and they are ruined. I put two layers of foil on top of the pan, 4.5 pounds of rib rack, and two layers of foil on top of the ribs to seal them in, after they were fine for the first couple of uses. I cooked them for 4 hours at 250 and 30 minutes at 450. None of them warrants any damage according to the product specifications. I guess I'm stuck with them now that it happened after my return period. I'm trying to get a hold of the company to see if I can return in another way.

👤It was a great price at the time of purchase. I used it for the first time to cook chicken wings. The chicken fat was cooking in the pan when I cleaned it. The baked on fat took the non-stick coating with it. The second pan has been fine since I put down wax paper to catch drippings. I use it all the time, but wax paper is your friend at higher temperatures. Non-stick spray oil on the grate is not easy to clean, but it is sturdy and helps clean immensely.

👤We used these pans for five months to cook bacon in the oven at 400 degrees. We have always used nonscratching utensils and cleaning pads. There has been some minor staining over time, but it was only a cosmetic issue and did not affect the pan's performance. The picture shows the surface beginning to oxidize last week. I'll try another brand next time.

👤Our last set was warped pretty badly and I bought these because they don't warp or bend easily. I took that as a good sign when I saw these heavy pans. We have used ours multiple times a week and so far no one has bent, warped, or altered their shape. Our food cooks faster and more evenly on these pans compared to our old ones. There is a slight appearance on the surface after a few uses but that doesn't bother me as long as they continue to perform as they have. I would recommend these to my other cooking friends if they wanted to do the same.

👤The baking sheet I own is the worst I have ever owned. I used the first set twice before the coating bubbled and peeled. Maybe it was something I did wrong. They sent me a new set for free after I filed a claim. I used the new set 4 times and the same result...bubbling and peeling! Don't waste your money! You can find better quality pans at Walmart.

👤The large surface area of the pans made it possible to fit a lot of potatoes at one time. I am having health issues that lead me to look at things I have overlooked. This is a review of the Baking Sheets, not a health seminar, so I will simply say that I am eliminating anything that could be contributing to having heavy metals in my system. I am not saying these baking sheets are the cause of my issues, but I will show you why I will no longer be using them. I use these BS twice a day for about two months. When I washed them prior to using them, I noticed that the soap looked gray, because I washed off some of the aluminum. In a rush to use the BS, I noticed some sort of metallic debris on the paper towel, after wiping off excess water with a paper towel. This has been happening after each wash. I was able to fit so much on the tray that I overlooked it. I discovered recently that my body is showing signs of too much heavy metals and I am taking actions to limit them. It took about 3 paper towels to clean up the mess. I've been cooking with these BS since April of this year. I've thrown them away.

👤I ordered Nordicware pans and USA pans at the same time, and used them both for the first time, so there's no difference in age. I baked gingerbread cookies, which were cracked on the Nordicwear pans, and needed a spatula to remove them, but the USA Pan cookies came off without a spatula needed. I can't speak to the wear of either or anything other than these cookies, so take this review as you will.

👤You can roast vegetables under a broiler or at 450 degree F, and cooked-on oil doesn't affect the pan's stickiness. This is all aluminum with steel around the edges so it doesn't warp. The pan is very heavy. My mom gave me an aluminum sheet pan when I moved out on my own. I have been abusing this thing for a decade. My mom had it before me. I have a small family of my own and my husband likes roasted veggies, but I like to make my own food at night. I'm looking for a sturdy one to go with my old beat up one. They would twist or warp over 400 degrees. It didn't seem like the price made a difference. I had cheap and expensive ones. At 400, they went funny. I assumed all pans did that, but I found this one. Actually, two. I now have three pans. I use the old one and the new one for veggies, and the third for baking cookies, so it will stay cleaner and stick free. The metal is really smooth and these are not sticky. These are a good choice if you're afraid of chemicals in your food. To make it easier to remove food from the pan, use a fat.

👤Silicone handles will be helpful, I love these baking sheets. I need pans to replace my baking sheets. They have other goodies on the website. I'm always looking to support local and small businesses, I was unaware this was a family owned business.

👤I was happy to find it on Amazon, and I was also happy to know that the items in the oven are from a small family.

👤These sheets are very nice. They're easy to clean. I have only had them a short time, so I can't vouch for their longevity, but they seem to be well-made.

👤The dents were there before I used them. It looks tacky since I just bought these. The rest of my review was well packaged. There are dents in the large tray in the Amazon box. I will post pictures of them because they look new but have dents in the bottom of the tray. I might return them. The red handles are as hot as the tray. This is a false advertisement. I had my oven at 350 and these Silicone handles are hot. It's ridiculous. The stars are false advertising and the trays are damaged. I want to love them.

👤The handles are easy to clean. One came out of the oven, but they are a bit thin. After cooling down, it might be heat related due to the material. It could be problematic to be cautious with what you are baking. The small one was the only one I had that problem with. I really like them.

👤I was very excited to find a set of non-stick baking sheets that were affordable. I didn't know this was a small family owned business until I saw the postcard insert in the package. When I tried to wipe it off with Dawn, warm water, and a soft plastic bristled brush, the non-stick coating began to wipe off with it. I didn't think I needed to spray it with Pam. The non-stick coating is a good purchase, but it will not last very long. A customer service representative apologized to me after I posted the review. They offered to send me a new product or give me a refund, and I received one. I have adjusted my review from 3 to 4 stars because of the concern they had.

👤I like the handles. It's easier to get the sheets out of the oven. I use the old ones since I am not the only one who cooks, but the newer ones don't get the papers since some people can't follow directions. I recycled my old ones.

👤This is a nice set of pans. The diversity of sizes is the main reason I chose this set. I have more opportunities to bake multiple pans of something at the same time with 3 different sizes. I can use the smallest pan in the RV oven. I love this set.

👤I bought this because it matches my cookware. Cookie sheet is completely different. I have had it for about six months. I bought it just for cookies, which I make about once every two weeks, washed it, and it is getting stained badly for being used just to bake cookies. Even though it was placed on the oven rack, it was all scratch up. I wish I hadn't bought it.

👤The first time I pulled out one of the cookie sheets, it got scratched from the Pyrex dish that was on top of it. Not impressed at all. I used this pan to bake cookies and to heat a frozen pizza. There are scratches on the front and back. Don't spend your money on these pans. I would like to get a full refund.

👤The ceramic finish is not great, there are many flaws in it, and when running your hands over it, there are a lot of nicks and bumps. A hair was found underneath the coating. The coating seems cheap and will chip easily.

👤The heat from the oven caused this baking sheet to warp and buckle in the oven and while being pulled out. The sheet is made of two different materials which expand/contract differently when exposed to heat. I'm not sure if it's the metal used or the coating. It's the last thing you want in a baking sheet. I heard a loud bang while roasting veggies and when I looked inside the oven, the pan looked like it had been hit by a car. All were unlevel. When it cooled down, it flattened out. I flung hot food all over the kitchen when I used it again, because it popped when I pulled it out of the oven. Thank goodness for oven mats. I really wanted to like this baking sheet but it's a really messy and dangerous tool to have in a kitchen.

👤I used this for baking cookies, with a mat on top. The green color on the bottom of the appliance has been chipping away at the corners since it was put in and out of the oven. I was not excited when I realized this item was not dishwasher safe, but I wish I'd just stuck with some good old steel. I would be returning this if I hadn't thrown away the packaging.

👤The GreenLife pots and pans are a beautiful color and the appeal of healthy cookware had me buying them. I used them for a week and they fell apart. I gave two stars because of the color. Here is a list of things that can go wrong when using the pots pans and bakeware together. 1. The turquoise finish left a turquoise covering over the top of my gas stove after a day of use. After a wash or two, the exposed aluminum rusted terribly, even though it was only a cosmetic and disappointing sight. This rust is frightening because it can harborbacteria. 2. The plastic spatula provided in the set with these began to wear off after a few weeks of using them. Our tortillas were torn and stuck to the bottom of the pans because the coat had lost so much of it's non-stick coating. The particles that are peeling off are going into your food, so please be aware of this. I have to worry that the aluminum bases of these pan may be in my food as well. 3. The "Stay- Cool Bakelite handle with soft touch" only stays cool to the touch until it burns, smokes, and char at the exposure of heat from the flame. The smell and fumes of burning plastic fill my home and sets of the smoke detectors are almost always used. The handles start smoking when boiling water. Burning plastic can cause dangerous emissions. Toxic chemicals are being released into the home and air way when these handles burn. I was sorely disappointed and out of money after purchasing this entire 14 piece set with 2 of their matching cookie sheets, loaf pan, casserole dish, and 12 cup cupcake tin. I wouldn't recommend buying these until they make some serious improvements. Once I have contacted the seller and requested a refund, I will update.

👤This pan is great for baking cookies. The texture on the bottom makes it stick to the pan. The obsidian black is a nice color. Nothing seems to stick yet for my baking, so it is easy to rinse clean. It is a nice quality baking sheet. I like the quality of it so much that I may buy more as it looks nice in my baking.

👤A very thick pan that is durable. I put foil down to protect the finish, but this went through the dishwasher without any issues. I use trays a lot when I smoke food, to keep the grease from dripping into fire.

👤These are wobbly when in hand. You can move it with both hands. I was looking for something that was strong.

👤This product is stained and burned after being used once.

👤The pan feels sturdy and heavier than most baking sheets. I was hoping that the air fryer feature on my oven would allow me to use the baking rack and pan together. The rack was clean in the dishwasher. It's a good pan.

👤I love these. It's easy to clean. Nothing sticks to them. They can take a lot of heat. Will recommend these to family and friends.

👤It's easy to clean heavy construction. Recommended.

👤I was tired of buying baking pans that seemed to warp, so I decided to give these a try, they look great and are easy to clean. Follow the guidelines. If you have the oven over 536-F, I can see that these pans are warped. Food was cooked evenly. I got the Noble Silver and it shows scratches very easily.

👤Great set! The small lip that keeps food from sliding off is an example. Might order another set.

👤It was bent and very flimsy. Very cheap.

👤The pans are nice. They cook-cookies-to fast because of the black finish. The bottoms burn quickly. I've made the same recipe for years. The problem is solved by lining them with paper.

👤Love it. The right size for cooking is single meals. It is easy to clean.

👤We love baking and these sheet pans are very durable.

👤I was so happy to find these. The small one is perfect for a lot of things. It is very easy to clean.

👤It's easy to clean and I'm loving it.

👤I like this. I have used it many times without paper products. I put my food in the holder and cook it. I don't use sprays. It doesn't clean with scrubbing. A great purchase. I hope it continues to be used.

👤Will be using it to make small cupcakes.