Best Clear Vanilla Extract for Baking Pure

👤I need to keep a lot of lemon extract because I can't get enough lemon desserts. I have tried a few other brands, but I prefer the McCormick brand. I use extract instead of grating lemons in my recipes because it's so much easier. Highly recommended.

👤I baked a lemon cake with lemon extract and it gave the whole cake a weird bleach flavor. The lemon extract in the cake batter and the frosting ruined the whole cake, because the recipe called for it. I baked the cake without the lemon extract and it tasted great.

👤The lemon extract is just plain bad, and I usually like McCormick extracts. The banana, coconut, butter, and peppermint are all good. Lemon is bad. I thought I used too much, but when I made it again, it was still bad.

👤I am not a fan of alcohol based flavors but this lemon extract does not seem to overwhelm the taste of lemon. I only have to use 1/2 of the lemon flavor for it to taste lemony, and I use it to make a quick microwave 6oz lemon cheesecake. It's awesome for mixing into a vanilla shake.

👤This is what I needed for my homemade cookies. The taste of my cookies is very nice. I will purchase more when needed. It won't expire if I use it right away. This brand is in my pantry.

👤It's great for cakes and pastries.

👤This is a very good deal. An ounce and a half is $5 in the grocery store. You already know it's quality because it has the great name of McCormick. A small amount goes a long way. It's used in cakes, frosting, and sugar cookies. If you bake a lot like I do, buying your extracts in bulk is the way to go. It costs a little more upfront, but it lasts a long time. I have bought this extract before and will continue to do so. Baking is fun!

👤Iike products. I live in the Baltimore area and went to school with Sherry. I know their wonderful products and trust their quality. They will never let you down. It's a bit pricey, but worth it.

👤I don't know what my expectations were but this product is not as lemony as I thought it would be. I have to use at least a small amount per bottle. The price is great for 8 ounces so I should still work out as cost effective even though I have to use more. I would definitely buy again.

👤The description in the images for the ingredients made me buy this. The image has a description of alcohol, oil of mint and water. I received a package with alcohol, water, and oil of mint. Over the years, I have bought this many times, as well as many other products from the same company. It seems like watering down their extracts is their new way of saving money. It's better to sacrifice quality and use more water to save money. It is not as strong as their old formula so be careful when buying this product. I would have bought another brand of extract if I wanted a strong one. Not happy at all. It's time to start buying from your competitors and suggest others do the same.

👤I love maple syrup and am low in calories. This gives me the flavor without the sugar. I make cheese waffles. They are made with mozarella cheese, egg and almond flour, and I mix in some cinnamon, and they are so good. There are recipes on-line for low-carb syrups that can be used to make maple syrup. I'm going to try that very soon.

👤I found a video on the internet where they showed you how to double your butter. You mix a pound of butter with a packet of gelatin and 1/2 cup of milk and whip the heli out of it. The end product is pretty nice, but not like real butter. The bell went off in my head when I ran across the butter substitute. I'll add it to the butter I'm making. This product has never been used before. I thought the cost was reasonable and would add it to my cakes. They delivered the shipment tonight and I'll be damned if it was a package of six. Oh no! They sent me the wrong thing, so I double checked and found out I was wrong, and then I checked the 6 pack option. I came here to warn the rest of you that I was going to use this product for more and more things, and now I'm glad I made the mistake. I opened it and tasted it, even though it was written that the flavor was poor. I did that butter flavor. I would be squeezing in the drop after eating my cakes and butter. I'm going to bake some bread after this. Can't wait to try it out. I saw a lady use on TV and ordered a beer. I have pulled my teeth waiting for dentures and am so bad for bacon that I thought of all the recipes I could use to make it taste better. What is the bacon flavor? The baby is going right next to the stove for easy access, I think I paid around $8. I'll be using this a lot. Try it out.

👤Very disappointed. They have changed the formula. No more the smell of raspberries. It tastes like alcohol. Their other products are awesome. It's time to start looking for something else. Over the last several years, I've bought a lot of this stuff. It's a pity.

👤Irreplaceable! I couldn't detect a change in the flavor of the regular brownie mix when I tried another brand. I was delighted when I found this on line, as I have used it many times and there is nothing like it in my experience. I am a happier cook because my baking is back to its previous taste. Jean Post.

👤Almond extract is used as a weapon.

👤I use more almond extract in my baking than I do in vanilla. If you want to get a compliment on the white frosting and icing, use almond extract instead of vanilla. I am now making my own version of the dessert, but I still use the same brand as the other one.

👤This stuff tastes like cherries. I add it to my food. It is delicious.

👤I don't understand the positive reviews. I was deceived. The extract has a strong alcohol scent. I used a small amount in the banana and blueberry cake to try it out. The cake was almost ruined by the off-flavor. I threw the bottle. I hope you won't be tricked like I was.

👤I use low fat milk, almond milk, etc, as my sweetner, and I add to the shakes to kill the taste of whey. Don't need a lot, enjoy!

👤This extract is my favorite. I will use it to make my sister sugar scrubs. She loves it! The bottle was undamaged despite one of the boxes being open a little bit.

👤I love the product and use it regularly. It wasn't available in the stores, so I'm glad it was on Amazon.

👤I have ordered this product 39 times. The label was different this time. It smelt like a chemical. Don't order! I have asked for a refund.

👤There was a sticker with a bar code on the bottle. I used a few drops in my tea and didn't think much of it. It tasted terrible. I had to peel the sticker off to see that it was covering the May 2010 date. I'm very disappointed that a product you ingest is not mentioned that it's past the manufacture expiration date. This product is out of date and has made me feel unwell all morning.

👤This product contains a controversial extract. You might want to research this ingredient before buying this product. Is it not possible to have 100% pure stevia?

👤The water solution separated from the Stevia within a few months. There is no option for a refunds since it takes a few months for liquid potency to change. Not happy.

👤When I read about the glycemic index and how sugar-free sweeteners can cause aninsulin reaction in your system, I was new to the diet. If you've been living sugar-free for a while, that's a lot to digest. This product is the best solution for me. It's very sweet. More than it has a right to be. Each day I use a small amount in my coffees. It's great for making any beverage you could dream up sweeter. Cucumber lemonade? It's phenomenal. You cannot use this as a straight sugar replacement for baking, but you can use it to replace straight sweetness. Where is the Amazon subscription option now?

👤Don't buy it if you don't like it. I bought this one because I was told the flavor of the brand was important. Even if it comes from a plant, it still tastes horrible. I was able to return the product. I'm happy about that.

👤I was very disappointed in the way this order was handled. I don't know if the product has been contaminated.

👤Sweet Drops are made of liquid Stevia. They give you the sugar you want, but with no calories or artificial sugars. I have been ordering these for a long time and am happy with the product. I use it in both my coffee and cooking. I sweetened the pears with a few drops. They can be used in place of sugar. The dropper gives you the correct amount. Highly recommended. If you think my review helped you, please let me know.

👤I switched over to this stuff after years of using sucralose. I wasn't a fan at first, but it has grown on me. Despite what the company claims, it does have a slight bitter taste, but it is not as bad as other brands. I need to use double the recommended amount to get a desired level of sweetness, which will mean I go through the bottle a bit faster. I've been using it for a couple of weeks now and I think it will last me several months, which is quite good value for money.

👤Very disappointing! The manufacturer said that this was the same as their smaller bottles. This is a lie. There is more water in the large bottle than there is oil. The amounts and volume are not correct. The ingredients are listed according to their amount. The number one ingredient is alcohol. The oil is the last one in the larger bottle and the water is the first in the smaller bottle. That makes this very watered down. If you purchase this, I would suggest doubling the amount of measure in your recipes. Either way, skip this purchase. It was very disappointing.

👤This was a week. It's on the label, but late it has any SMELLTHEY sell it. "PURE PEPPERMINT EXTRACT" is not the real thing, it's just the name of the substance.

👤I buy small bottles of McCormick all the time. This is nothing like this.

👤I decided to listen to the majority of reviewers rather than the minority that said this didn't have much peppermint flavor. The minority have it right. The extract has a weak flavor. I would expect better from him. I don't write a lot of reviews but I want to add my voice to the minority so don't buy this! A big bottle, even at a good price per ounce, is still worthless if it doesn't have enough flavor to do the job it's intended for.

👤Small bottles of McCormick extract are typically found in stores, but this product is not as concentrated. I use alcohol based, watersoluble peppermint extract to mix with white distilled vinegar for a natural ant spray. I'm making larger batches because my formula is popular with friends. I thought a big bottle of extract would be more economical than small bottles. It was a bad decision. The scent of this product is very weak compared to the small bottle formula of peppermint. The spray used to leave a mint scent. The spray leaves the surfaces smelling like a bakery and I need to add more. Not desirable. I'm going back to the consumer versions. Is anyone in need of a cloyingly sweet minty extract?

👤The smell of mint is offensive to insects and rodents. It was perfect. I use it to clean countertops at our lake house, and it's a great substitute for a cleaner made of steel. It makes it shine. Who knew?

👤It's a large amount of liquid, 1 pt, but the flavor is much weaker than smaller, more expensive bottles of McCormick Anise Extract I have bought at a Super Market. I would have the Super Market extract, but I had to add more of this. I didn't know if the difference was greater or less, but I think the 1 pt extract from Amazon is a better buy. Since I only use the extract once a year for Pizzelles, I will have to keep the rest until next year and hope that it doesn't degrade or I misplace it.

👤The produce is called "pure peppermint extract" but it isn't pure at all and can't be legal. I don't know why it asks you to rate the thickness of the extract, since water isn't thick at all. I haven't even bothered using it in cooking yet because it smells so weak. The bottle pours right out of the bottle when I put the lid back on after removing the seal. Don't buy.

👤The caps on the tops are unable to be opened as they have been updated recently. I was able to get one of them off after about 30 minutes. I have been trying to get it off for almost 2 hours. The product is worthless if you can't use it. I wouldn't buy this from them until they fixed their packaging. Don't waste your money on things you can't use.

👤We couldn't open the bottle because we couldn't taste the product. I didn't think this would happen, but I have to throw out all of the baking products I am making until I can get a bottle of vanilla that the cap can be removed from. The lid was unable to be opened. He couldn't open the jar when I brought it to him.

👤I can't be picky in the age of COVID19. You have to shop based on what's available. I tried a lot of brands and foods that I had never had before. I've always liked the taste of the powder version of vanilla and these versions suspended in liquid extract just don't seem to work as well. It tastes like it evaporates out if you use twice as much as the recipe suggests. It's not as good value for money because I have to use more of it. If you are making banana bread, it's better than nothing.

👤I didn't have time to go to Marshalls and it was delivered to the door in 2 hours. The product is similar to similar products in other stores. The cap is difficult to open, and that annoyed me the most. I clean it with a paper towel after each use. It still gets stuck.

👤If this extract just didn't deliver the same flavor as the original, that would be one thing, but it also has a chemical smell. It's not a typical alcohol smell, it's a more synthetic one. The chemical smell is still there even though I tried to improve it by taking a whole vanilla bean. I bake muffins with various brands of extract. Simply Organic is the best brand of Whole Foods that I've bought. Simply Organic vanilla is less expensive than Penzey's, and it is at least as good. The brand is worthless.

👤Excellent quality product. A better way to pour it into measuring spoons without spilling or over pouring would be appreciated.

👤It's not like the flavor of vanilla.

👤Unless you buy in bulk, you won't find another vanilla extract at this price point. This vanills is an example of Whole Foods Market's quality.

👤Not impressed with the butter flavor extract. It does not have a strong butter taste.

👤I needed butter to make me want to eat it. I replaced beans with butter to reduce fat. I added butter to the hummus and made it taste like butter. The butter flavor was spot on for my taste buds.

👤I have used the products from Wilton for many years and was dismayed to see them disappear from Michael's. Thank goodness for Amazon! It's important for the frosting to stay white. It makes baked products taste better. I use it in my baking supplies.

👤I use butter flavoring for ice cream. I used to do cake decorating and I know that the quality of the product is good. The butter smell and taste was not present in this flavoring. It actually smelled bad. I got rid of it. Artificial flavorings and water are the first ingredients. Nothing about butter.

👤I should have read the reviews. I put it in an oil sprayer because I can't have fat. I wanted it for popcorn. I could smell the butter flavor as I sprayed it. The taste was more like a chemical than butter. It might taste better in actual recipes, but I don't think it's an advantage. Disappointed.

👤I tried to open the bottle. It has a strong taste. It smells like butter. I added it to the cake man to make it kick my butter cake up a notch. My customer said the cake was very good.

👤Have been using this for a long time. It has a great flavor and takes very little to cook. It was recommended in a class a long time ago, and I have not found anything that works better for me when I need to make a standard icing with shortening. I have used it with other types as well and have been pleased with it.

👤I've used many products from Wilton, but never the clear imitation butter flavoring. I used it today to make some muffins. So far, so good, I used just a little.

👤This may be good for sweet creations. It's not suitable for making food taste like butter. Please let me know if anyone knows of a butter that isn't sweet.

👤One customer wrote that the flavor is very intense so I am cautious with the amount I use. I haven't figured out how much product I should add, but I have used it in cookies, cakes and even pancakes. I have not tasted it yet. I will keep trying.

👤This was bought for mixing with popcorn. It's a waste of money. The flavor was so bad we had to throw it away.

👤A butterbeer was made for a Harry Potter themed party.

👤This is great for making cookie dough/cake batter flavoured stuff. It works well with almond/vanilla extract. Adding butter flavour without the butter is very helpful if you're a vegan, but only a few drops give a lot of flavour.

👤I can't make banana bread because I have bad candida. I used blanched almond flour and zucchini to make a bread and then added banana extract, chopped nuts, and wow! We used a lot of both of them. It turned out great. It was the best bread I've ever made. My wife ate my banana nut bread muffins. I made strawberry muffins after getting the strawberry extract. This stuff is serious and I was skeptical. I couldn't tell the difference between real bananas and fake ones. 2 large eggs, 1 cup olive oil, oravoc oil, 12 cup salt, or whatever you like, 12 cup baking powder, or ground ginger, add liquid mixture to the recipe. Cook 350F for 70 minutes and mix almond flour with chopped almonds or any nut. I hope this helps someone.

👤This stuff is great. I missed bananas when I was following the way of life of the Keto way of life. I add banana extract along with a dash of vanilla to my waffle batter and then add some sugar free maple syrup and some pecans to finish it off. The banana flavor is nice. I'll be trying low-fat banana nut muffins/bread next.

👤I'm a chef and baker trying to live a low sugar lifestyle. This is the best banana pure extract I've found. If you can't afford it, buy pure extracts. I recommend.

👤This stuff is great. It tastes like banana and not a fake one. I wish it included a dropper or application wand. I had to buy an eyedropper to use it because it pours too fast and is too much. I am on a chocolate shake to lose weight. I add a few drops of this to make it taste better. It's very good. If you want pure banana flavour without the aftertaste of fake banana, you will love this.

👤So good! Just like a fresh banana! I make mug bread with this. The bomb is here! A mug with butter in it. Add 1 egg, heavy cream, banana extract, and brown sugar sub. Microwave for 1 min 20 seconds or until firm, and then eat the almond flour, ground flaxseed, and baking powder.

👤I found a few recipes that called for banana extract and that is what brought me here. No real bananas are allowed. They are all possible with this extract. I had tried another popular brand before but it wasn't as good. My household loves this one. I recommend this product to everyone. To explain the flavor of the dessert with the Nilla wafers and sliced bananas. That is what this tastes like. It was delicious!

👤It's not possible to find a product like this in retail stores or specialty markets. There are lots of imitation banana extract out there, but the real thing has been out of my grasp for a long time. I was thrilled to discover this product on Amazon. A large bottle with a screw on top. It tastes just as good as a fresh banana, and it smells just as good. The extract doesn't have the same taste as a real banana. A little goes a long way, so less is more until you find the right dose for the amount of liquid or batter being used. I use a large eye dropper instead of pouring directly from a bottle. It makes life simpler and neater.

👤I have used the same paste from the same company for many years. The NM is a thick and sticky product that has a nice rich aroma and is almost black in color from how much of the bean is in it. It's almost clear with a few bits. It is quite sweet and thinner than a paste. I am uneasy that there is no country of origin on this product. I threw the whole bottle away because I was leery of its origin. It's a pity.

👤The paste is supposed to be very thick. This is not alcohol. Not what I was expecting. If you want an authentic version of the bean paste, stick with the expensive brands.

👤The ingredients on the package are not what is advertised. This is not a paste. The smell is very faint. This is not a mixture of brown water and syrup. I'm not sure if I can get a refund.

👤Since we were stuck at home for the first time in several years, the wife wanted a birthday cake. Her favorite cake is called "Swedish Princess Cake". The Swedish Princess Cake is one of the most difficult cakes to make. It is completely covered by a Marzipan 'dome'. There are three layers of sponge cake inside, frosted with lots of jam, pastry cream and whipped cream. I couldn't find the recipe for the paste in any of the stores I checked. This paste is fit for royalty. I will use it instead of plain vanilla extract in future recipes.

👤It wasn't a rich flavor. Was not a paste. It was a liquid gel. I added it to my baked goods, but I could not taste it. I had to add another store bought brand of pure vanilla flavor to my baked goods. This product was very strong. Very disappointed and will never buy again.

👤This taste is great. It is a liquid that is slightly thicker than regular vanilla. It is not near a paste.

👤I've been buying the brown bottle for a long time and they're charging too much. This product is equally good and I like to support smaller companies.

👤This stuff is disgusting. It is the first time I have ever bought a paste like that. I have been baking for years, I am a mother of five, and I am familiar with the scent, flavor, and taste of vanilla. This junk tastes like plastic tasting, and it does not taste anything like vanilla at all. It is gross. I bought 2 bottles of it, thinking I was getting a great deal, but after tasting it, I started looking into the ingredients on the bottle. None of them are what they should be. If this were a real paste, it would only contain a few ingredients, including the beans, extract, and sugar. If you want a paste-glycerin that isn't alcoholic, it should have some kind of substance like a substance from the plants. I can tell you that this gross gel-like goo doesn't taste like any of those ingredients. It doesn't smell or taste like anything. It tastes terrible. I threw away both bottles immediately, and I will consider myself lucky that I didn't consume any of the disgusting junk they used to make this with.

👤I run out of cooking time fast because I love cooking and use it on everything. The product is great. A friend of mine once suggested to use a few drops on my grilled steaks to enhance the flavor and aroma and it worked. I was asked what I had done to the steaks. Steaks and a secret ingredient vanished.

👤It has a pleasant taste. It seems like it has a good shelf life.

👤The flavor of this vanilla works well in baking. I have been using this for baking cookies, and have noticed that the flavor holds well after baking, since I originally bought this to use for whipped cream and frosting. I will continue to buy this clear extract from Wilton.

👤It's perfect for keeping white cake white. It does not taste artificial.

👤I had to remove it. I will not ruin my baking with it. LorAnn clear is a better product. Sorry to Wilton!

👤I like this product. I've been using it for a long time. The icing is white because of the clear color.

👤It arrived on time.

👤I used this for the first time today and it was clear, strong and smelled great, it was cheaper than a bottle from Walmart. I wish it was cheaper than it is, but I will order again when I need it.

👤I only trusted the title words when I searched for it and discovered it was artificial. They need to make it clear.

👤It was expected that it would taste artificial. If you are looking to keep your "whites white", then this is a good idea. You can buy this for about $6.00 in a local store. I chose the name Wilton. If you can find a clear vanilla for a lower price, then you should do that.

👤It was a real search. It should be clear that this is artificial.

👤The alcohol may be based on methanol. There is a The taste of alcohol is a little subdued after it has flashed off. If you are baking stuff for other people, the price point leaves some value.

👤Water is the first ingredient. The second substance is sugar. There are three things that are third is propylene glycol. I should have checked more carefully.

👤I was convinced after seeing the reviews and price. One could not help but be attracted to the cheap price of vanilla extract when it is available. Ah ha! Don't click immediately if you're looking for pure vanilla extract. We had a chance to look a little more closely at this product after we received it, as it is not a pure vanilla extract, but aBakingVanilla extract. It does perform well, but it does give non-baked items a slightly minty flavor, which is different to the rounded and warm flavor of baked goods. During this crisis, a replacement for vanilla was not terrible.

👤It was a complete waste of money, but it also cost me money for my other ingredients and time. I made 1 batches of cookies with this, and it added no flavor at all. When you search for it, it is listed under pure vanilla extract. I'm not sure if there's any extract at all. It's not right when I search for pure vanilla extract on Amazon. The cost of dumping out this bottle and throwing out my batches leaves me angry at Watkins and Amazon. I have had better results with artificial extracts. The only thing I can say is that it smelled nice after I dumped the entire bottle into my sink.

👤Watkins was a brand name that we used in our household. I bought that brand when I was looking for a reasonable price. I guess you get what you pay for. This is the worst I have ever tried. It has a strong smell. It doesn't taste like it's from a movie.

👤This is not a pure extract. There are artificial flavors, alcohol, and water in this picture. There is Sulfides. I can't use this product because of my family members. I will try to find a use for the bottle, but it will be sitting around for a while.

👤I really like Watkins products, but this one missed the mark. It's awful. I bought it in September of last year because the price was right and it smelled cheap, and I thought the bad reviews were because it was expensive. I've never smelled imitation vanilla before, but this is what I thought it would smell like. I use it in baked goods and it makes the food taste different, even though I cut it in half. I've used it about 15 times, but I can't seem to like it anymore. It's not real tasting. I wouldn't recommend this.

👤It is not pure. That is one of the ingredients. The ingredient is listed as more than the one that's called vanilla. This is not acceptable and does not taste like other vanillas. Several of my family wanted to know why my desserts tasted different during the Thanksgiving dinner.

👤If you receive a different label than the double strength one, don't be alarmed, it's called baking vanilla and it's a new label. I have been using Watkin's products for a long time. This product is used by my Grandmother, Mother and I. I used to sell Watkin's products. I ordered the 11oz version because my personal rep retired and I didn't have a local one. The seller is also Watkins, and the price was fair. I was shocked when I saw a different name and label for this product. I immediately called Watkins to get clarification. The new label is because the rep confirmed that they were changing the name. She said that there is still a mix of old and new labels out there, but that my item is the new label and completely safe and real. I told her that I thought the new label should be in the stock ad on Amazon, or at least advise potential customers of the change with a caveat. I thought I was getting a fake product. I think so. The strength is what I love about this product. This product doesn't bake your baked goods. The taste is very strong. I always use a minimum of 1 capful per recipe, even though they say you can use very little. This is the best I have ever used. No comparison! My adult children use this brand of products. I paid full price for this item. My thoughts are my own and I don't pay for them. My opinions are based on what I have experienced.