Best Watkins Clear Vanilla Extract for Baking

Watkins 3 Jul 2022 10+ Comments Open

1. Watkins Food Coloring

Watkins Food Coloring

Derived from pure vegetable juices and spices.

Brand: Watkins

👤I bought these thinking they were natural, but after reading someone else's review, I realize they are not. I'm not sure how they can put 100% natural on the label. I could have bought the coloring at the store and gotten a better result. I used it to color the cake batter. The package doesn't say not to use in baking. The batter was vibrant and beautiful when I mixed it with the colors. The cake layers were baked in the oven. By the time the layers were done cooking, the colors were gone. The emerald green layer looked like a fuzzy mold. I don't recommend buying these. I will never do that again. They are not natural.

👤I have tried many natural food dyes to accommodate my customers. I liked these because they are less expensive than other brands and the colors work great in natural dyes. These are not made with 100% natural vegetable juices and spices as the package claims. I was really disappointed after reading the ingredients and realizing they still contain chemicals I was trying to avoid. I really wanted to like these.

👤Polysorbate 80 is one of the ingredients that can make you claim to be natural.

👤Natural colors! I was able to do a rainbow cake with those great colors.

👤The red coloring has sugar in it. My son has a very restricted diet and he cannot have sugar. He was excited to be able to make things red. The green was so thick it wouldn't drain out of the tube and the lid popped off, dumping half of the bottle into the frosting I was making. The colors are lovely and I appreciate having a natural alternative. I wish I'd read the ingredients before ordering. This is not what I was hoping for. If you buy them, be aware of the viscosity and remove the lid if they get thick.

👤Other reviewers have noted that the red comes out more purple. The blue and green are lovely shades of calm. I had an issue with one bottle being blocked with a strand but it was removed and the bottle worked fine. If you don't expect these to be like artificial dyes, you'll enjoy them. I used them to color. I tried to combine yellow and red to make orange, but ended up with brown. After sitting in the fridge overnight, that became muddy yellow. Not sure if you could make orange with this set. I made a purple with red and blue.

👤I needed a small bottle to get a green color in the dough for my Christmas cookies, but I bought this to make them. I baked the first batches and low and behold the cookies are pale in color and the kids like them, but the rest had to be decorated with red and green sprinkles. I have never had a problem with the products I have bought before. I think it's a good idea to say on the label that it's all natural and juices and veg are used in the manufacture, but if it's not going to hold a color in baking I think it's a bad idea.

2. Danncy Mexican Vanilla Extract Plastic

Danncy Mexican Vanilla Extract Plastic

Does not Contain Alcohol.

Brand: Danncy

👤I was expecting something from Danncy MexicanVanilla. Most of the bad reviews are for people who want to replace clear or standard vanilla with this one, and have never tasted Mexican vanilla. Most Mexican vanilla beans are cured using sun drying and smoking. Smoking is not part of the curing process. The smokey, spicy, cinnamon like note that the wood used to smoke and cure the Mexican beans give is due to the MexicanVanilla orchid's flavor profile. I have been buying Danncy Vanilla for my home and professional use for over 20 years, and the wood has the same flavor compounds that are found in the vanilla bean. I think of Mexican clear Vanilla when I think of perfect and exactly what I want.

👤It was on time and as expected. I have read a lot of bad reviews about this product, but it is exactly what I expected. The reviewers must be used to that. This is not alcohol. I remember smelling it as a child. My mom used to use MexicanVanilla when we were young. They lived in Tucson, AZ and would go to Nogales to buy it. We were always looking for it, but neither of us knew the brand, because my sister and I now live back east and my parents have passed on. I was happy when I saw that rooster and red label. I got a surprise for my sister. Thanks so much!

👤I would have liked to read the reviews before buying this product. I was very excited about the price. I attended baking and pastry school. This looks and tastes like water with a very mild hint of vanilla to it, and I have plenty of experience with using it. It is very thin and hard to describe, but I am not sure if it has any real flavor. Very disappointed. I hope people will know that I am upfront with what I found. I won't be buying again.

👤False adverised! It's weakly scented water, not a flavor. Zero stars and not returnable. Don't get it. Prime members get the shaft late, non-refundable, and nonreturnable. I'm starting to feel bad about Amazon Prime. Also, for now. It's worthless for deserts, not drinks. It's alcohol free, flavor free, and free from any use.

👤I had high hopes for this Mexican flavor, but it tastes terrible. I don't understand why this product is getting different reviews. You don't know which lot you're getting, is the quality irregular? I will never buy this product again.

👤This product is terrible. I bake cakes that ruin Easter cakes. It has a perfumey scent, but it is not like vanilla. This isn't the same as the other one if you're used to using it. It made my tongue feel weird. I don't know what is in this but it's a different story than what we're used to. They won't accept returns so I'm throwing them out. A beautiful cake ruin and a lot of money. I want my money back. Don't buy this product if it claims it. I don't understand how anyone who bakes could rate this as close to vanilla as possible.

3. Watkins Vanilla Flavor Extract Packaging

Watkins Vanilla Flavor Extract Packaging

Any recipe that needs to be pure white can be made with this product. Product 1: Gourmet flavor without color that does not freeze out. Product 1: no artificial colors. Corn Syrup Free, Kosher is the first product. Pure extract is perfect for baking, flavoring drinks and more. Product 2 is made from natural oils. Product 2 has no artificial colors or flavors. Product 2 is non-GMO, corn syrup free and Kosher.

Brand: Watkins

👤I was familiar with the Watkins brand when it was sold door to door. I first learned about their pepper and their extract from that location. This flavor is artificial. I have used it in cooking and baking for over 70 years. The almond extract is wonderful.

👤I was praying this was not like that, after I purchased MexicanVanilla Clear Extract. The Watkins Clear Vanilla Extract was very good. This is going to be my go-to choice because of the quality and low price. I like it and am very happy.

👤Watkins products have been used for over 50 years.

👤This is the ticket for my coffee. I use a natural sugar substitute, and the Watkins vanilla puts my morning routine on the right track, because it's a natural sugar substitute. Great product.

4. Watkins Gourmet Organic Vanilla Powder

Watkins Gourmet Organic Vanilla Powder

USDA certified organic. The non-GMO project has been verified. Gourmet spices and herbs are of the highest quality. A bottle made of recycled material.

Brand: Watkins

👤I love this product. It was delicious! I have bought it twice now, which is bad. * Only one of the three packs arrives. That is not a good price for a single bottle. ! It is listed wrong. AMAZON! I need my money back. It is difficult to get customer service with Amazon since Covid has hit. Amazon is a lifesaver for me through this time. I need to return something. The service has gone down a lot. This product is not listed correctly. You will only be receiving one bottle. It is too expensive for one.

👤This is a good product, but disappointing when it comes to the lemon part. I was looking for a lemon pepper with no salt and Watkins was the only company that could do it. I wanted to get a lemon flavor for my grilled chicken and fish. There was no lemon and lots of pepper. Amazon doesn't allow food returns, so you have to pay $25 for ground pepper.

👤I used Watkins potato salad seasoning in my potato salad. I missed it when Watkins stopped making it. We like it.

👤For several years I have told everyone that Watkins' Black Pepper is in a league of it's own. When I saw the organic version, I was so excited that they had found a way to make the best pepper even better. The 3 pack was a good deal. I thought differently. The original Watkins ground black pepper is far inferior to this pepper. The black pepper cans are better than this product. The taste is ok, but the texture is fluffy and bland. You know what I mean. When you buy a cheap salt and pepper combo because you need a new salt and pepper, you end up randomly using the pepper half and realize how cheap it is. How it could blow away if you opened the microwave door too quickly. It is fluffy. The pepper is gross. If I am buying pepper, I either want a coarse chunk from a peppercorn grinder or I want it to flow like sand from a shaker and cling to anything moist that it touches. I just emptied the container from the pencil sharpener over my food. That is what this pepper does. I have three jars of it.

👤A fair life core makes a great latte.

👤This is a good option from the liquid extract. It is more convenient and the flavor is great. I drink coffee or chocolate on my pastries.

👤The flavor is almost non-existant, but I like a good price. It took half a bottle to make a bunch of noodles, but curry was used by the color, not the smell or taste. There is a wonderful, warm Aroma missing in the small bottle version of Gourmet, but there is immediate flavor with 2 ounces. Watkins went on the cheap with the "organic" label. Can we get the GOURMET back at the original price of $7?

👤Watkin's has not on the cinnamon. It is possible to taste the flavor in the baked goods. I only buy Watkins black pepper. They will only have cinnamon. The house has a lot of smells.

5. Watkins Organic Original Gourmet Vanilla

Watkins Organic Original Gourmet Vanilla

USDA certified organic. The non-GMO project has been verified. All of the ingredients are derived. There are no artificial flavors or colors. Corn Syrup is Kosher.

Brand: Watkins

6. Watkins Caramel Flavor Natural Flavors

Watkins Caramel Flavor Natural Flavors

Quality ingredients include high in flavor and strength. There may be different packaging. It's easy to add some of your favorite flavors. Use for baked goods, ice cream, syrup, frostings, candies, breads, fruit sauces, and jellies. One of the widest flavors is available. A little goes a long way.

Brand: Watkins

👤I would have left 5 stars if I had bought this product before the last two purchases, but they have changed how this is made and it is terrible. I bought several bottles of Watkins caramel extract from Amazon. The last bottle I purchased had a strange taste when I used it, but it was not a dark brown, it was a light brown. I thought I had a bad batches. I ordered another bottle and it is just as bad. I don't know what they've changed, but the taste is terrible when used for baking and they need to change it back.

👤Do not order this if you are looking for something free. I ordered the extract and not the flavoring because the ingredients list for the extract did not include sugar. I was sent the flavoring even though I ordered the extract. I can not return it. I can not use the sugar because it is in something else.

👤I like the flavor of caramel. I was trying to stop using the kind of ice cream you should only use for top ice cream. When I found this Watkins Carmel Extract that tastes like caramel, it was the first time I'd tasted it. I was saved! I think you can do it, it only takes about 1/2 of a cup. But not here. There are many uses. I've tried it in cookies, breakfast shakes, ice cream, and coffee. I have to use caramel. I only had a few weeks with it. He is.

👤Did not see what was pictured. The ingredients are not the same. Disappointing! The ingredient list should include: Propylene glycol, artificial flavor, water, caramel color. It contains sulfur.

👤The ingredients on the box are not what I was shown. I am unable to return it.

👤I missed the old glass bottles because they were the real thing. The plastic seems to lose some of the flavor, but I guess it's just the way it is. I used it to make my apples on the stove with a caramel flavor. They can be used as a side dish to backed chicken or turkey dishes or as a dessert with ice cream.

👤This has a bad flavor. I've tried to get used to it. It's not happening. Watkins used to have a good caramel. Maybe they changed the formula? It runs down the bottle when I pour it on the spoon.

👤The extract has a great caramel taste and is very convincing in baked goods or syrups. I use it in oatmeal, yogurt, tea, and even a few drops of tea with almond milk. It's a dark-colored product, so be careful. If you spill something, make sure to clean it up immediately or it will be difficult to remove. I've never let it sit that long, but I assume it could stain. I didn't remove a star, but from my own carelessness, I've ended up with a mess a couple of times.

👤I ordered it thinking it would be the extract. I was wrong. This is lighter than I have ever seen before. It doesn't taste right. I was not happy with my purchase.

7. Watkins Baking Vanilla Extract Almond

Watkins Baking Vanilla Extract Almond

Watkins most popular baking extracts are combined. Watkins BakingVanilla's bake and freeze proof blend is ideal for baking. Watkins ClearVanilla extract is a gourmet flavor that does not bake or freeze out. Watkins Almond Extract is made from natural oils. There are no artificial colors, non-GMO, Kosher.

Brand: Watkins

8. Watkins Original Gourmet Vanilla Packaging

Watkins Original Gourmet Vanilla Packaging

All naturally derived ingredients were used in this recipe. It is ideal for baking. There are no artificial colors or flavors. There is a note that contains Sulfites. Corn Syrup is Kosher.

Brand: Watkins

👤Water is the first ingredient. The second substance is sugar. There are three things that are third is propylene glycol. I should have checked more carefully.

👤I was convinced after seeing the reviews and price. One could not help but be attracted to the cheap price of vanilla extract when it is available. Ah ha! Don't click immediately if you're looking for pure vanilla extract. We had a chance to look a little more closely at this product after we received it, as it is not a pure vanilla extract, but aBakingVanilla extract. It does perform well, but it does give non-baked items a slightly minty flavor, which is different to the rounded and warm flavor of baked goods. During this crisis, a replacement for vanilla was not terrible.

👤It was a complete waste of money, but it also cost me money for my other ingredients and time. I made 1 batches of cookies with this, and it added no flavor at all. When you search for it, it is listed under pure vanilla extract. I'm not sure if there's any extract at all. It's not right when I search for pure vanilla extract on Amazon. The cost of dumping out this bottle and throwing out my batches leaves me angry at Watkins and Amazon. I have had better results with artificial extracts. The only thing I can say is that it smelled nice after I dumped the entire bottle into my sink.

👤Watkins was a brand name that we used in our household. I bought that brand when I was looking for a reasonable price. I guess you get what you pay for. This is the worst I have ever tried. It has a strong smell. It doesn't taste like it's from a movie.

👤This is not a pure extract. There are artificial flavors, alcohol, and water in this picture. There is Sulfides. I can't use this product because of my family members. I will try to find a use for the bottle, but it will be sitting around for a while.

👤I really like Watkins products, but this one missed the mark. It's awful. I bought it in September of last year because the price was right and it smelled cheap, and I thought the bad reviews were because it was expensive. I've never smelled imitation vanilla before, but this is what I thought it would smell like. I use it in baked goods and it makes the food taste different, even though I cut it in half. I've used it about 15 times, but I can't seem to like it anymore. It's not real tasting. I wouldn't recommend this.

👤It is not pure. That is one of the ingredients. The ingredient is listed as more than the one that's called vanilla. This is not acceptable and does not taste like other vanillas. Several of my family wanted to know why my desserts tasted different during the Thanksgiving dinner.

👤If you receive a different label than the double strength one, don't be alarmed, it's called baking vanilla and it's a new label. I have been using Watkin's products for a long time. This product is used by my Grandmother, Mother and I. I used to sell Watkin's products. I ordered the 11oz version because my personal rep retired and I didn't have a local one. The seller is also Watkins, and the price was fair. I was shocked when I saw a different name and label for this product. I immediately called Watkins to get clarification. The new label is because the rep confirmed that they were changing the name. She said that there is still a mix of old and new labels out there, but that my item is the new label and completely safe and real. I told her that I thought the new label should be in the stock ad on Amazon, or at least advise potential customers of the change with a caveat. I thought I was getting a fake product. I think so. The strength is what I love about this product. This product doesn't bake your baked goods. The taste is very strong. I always use a minimum of 1 capful per recipe, even though they say you can use very little. This is the best I have ever used. No comparison! My adult children use this brand of products. I paid full price for this item. My thoughts are my own and I don't pay for them. My opinions are based on what I have experienced.

9. Watkins Imitation Extract Butter Packaging

Watkins Imitation Extract Butter Packaging

It's perfect for baking, drinks and more. Butter extract has other natural flavors. Artificial colors or flavors are not allowed. Corn Syrup is Kosher.

Brand: Watkins

👤The taste of butter type extracts is a concern for me. I use it to make cookies with brown butter. If you smell the bottle. The smell of butter is not fresh. Several reviewers complain that it isn't imitation butter extract. This makes no sense. The packaging does not use the word butter. The smell of alcohol is sweet. I don't think I have ever smelled an extract like that. The majority of extracts use alcohol. Alcohol is a good oxidizer. When you use butter extract in baked goods? It is one of the best. As with any butter enhancing product? Please use it lightly and don't look at it!

👤I ordered the extract from Amazon because I can't find it in any local stores. I like baking with it because it adds butteriness to our baking that we didn't get in our alternative baking. I don't know how much they used, or if they were trying to replace the butter itself, but if you use it like any other baking extract, it will taste the same. It adds the butteriness you want without being overwhelming. It tastes close enough to fill in the missing gap that it doesn't taste 100% spot-on. If it's bothering you, then maybe use butter. The product is good. Although I have never had any problems ordering through Amazon, they sent the wrong thing, which my family cannot have because of their milk allergies. I was bugged. I ordered this from Amazon because I can't find the imitation anywhere, and they sent me exactly what I was trying to avoid. I don't have what I wanted for holiday baking, so I'll have to return it. Please review the orders carefully. I realize there are similar items out there, and perhaps the average baker would be thrilled to be given the genuine extract instead of the imitation, but there may be health reasons why they wanted the imitation! I can keep the butter extract, but I'll have to find someone to give it to. I'm not sure if it's worth trying to get the right thing again. I'm not happy.

👤This product is listed as butter flavoring but is actually am extract. For people looking for something dairy free, look elsewhere. It is a flavor. I'm not sure what it is. It tastes like butter and smells sweet. It would be a zero on a butteriness scale. I know that one only needs a small amount, but it should taste and smell like butter. It doesn't help to cook the alcohol out. I asked for a refund that was not as described.

👤I just received my order. I smelled it first. It smelled like alcohol. There is no butter smell or butter taste. I still have a bottle of Watkins extract. The smell of butter and the taste of butter is still there. Nothing stays the same in this crazy world. It tastes like alcohol. There is no list of alcohol on the original bottle. That's the main ingredient on the newer one. Watkins products have gone way down hill. Always trusted Watkins. This is not the real product that you used to sell, so I would like a full refund.

10. Watkins Vanilla Flavor Extract Packaging

Watkins Vanilla Flavor Extract Packaging

Any recipe that needs to be pure white can be baked with a premium baking staple. It does not bake or freeze out. Corn Syrup is Kosher.

Brand: Watkins

👤I thought I would save a few bucks by trying a imitation of pure vanilla extract. It would be a safe choice because this one was so highly rated. Huge mistake. Don't use this project if you're used to pure vanilla. It has a strong taste that is noticeable in cookies where I only used 1/2tsp.

👤After opening the bottle, a powerful chemical/ anti-freeze aroma lifted into the air and into my nose. I put a few drops on my finger to make sure I wasn't imagining anything. I was not imagining the horror. My husband has a limited sense of smell and taste. He was able to smell and taste the foul liquid. I apologized to any aquatic wildlife that may encounter it when I dumped it down the drain. I feel like a genius, having ordered this without checking to make sure it was natural, instead of man-made garbage. It's impossible to believe that these 4/5 star reviewers are drinking this hell juice. Order at your own risk.

👤I think Amazon never tasted actual Vanilla Extract. It doesn't taste good. The description is misleading because I have a specific need for it. This is not an extract or a sugar based flavor.

👤We have been buying this product from Walmart for years. It was out of stock at the supermarket and so I went to check it out on Amazon. I was happy that I checked here. I was always buying a bigger bottle for the same price as a small bottle. The product is free of corn syrup and has a pure fragrance that works great for baking and even in smoothies.

👤I knew that some customers hated the smell when I read the reviews. I decided to take a chance because others loved it. If you're in the same situation, learn from my mistake. This stuff is not nice. It made my cookie frosting taste better. The rest of the bottle was poured down the drain. Even though it costs an arm and a leg, I'll go back to natural vanilla extract. The savings are not worth much.

👤The fact that this bottle of Watkins vanilla is clear bothered someone who asked about it being a color. It was power of suggestion for me as well, when I read their concern. I bought it because a verified purchaser assured me that the clear was just as good as the Watkins brown vanilla. I was happy I did. I get a large bottle of Watkins, which is the best, because I use a lot of vanilla. This was a big deal. It's better than cheaper brands. Don't worry about the colorless. It's not possible to get this much flavor for such a low price. You'll like it if you try it.

👤I opened the package and there was no lid on the product. It wasn't hard to miss that it wasn't included since it was just that and some hot chocolate and an air bag. I'm not sure how someone can pack a bottle with no lid and not be able to close it when they use it. I saw a wet spot on the box when I turned the flavoring upside down, and since I won't use something that I don't know what was done to it, I have to throw it out. I'm not sure if it's an issue with the seal or if it's a hole. Since there was no lid, you have to wonder if someone did something to it. They still shipped it to me. I had to call to get another one. Customer service sent out another one and they decided to hold up another order of mine and ship them both. I sat here waiting for nothing to happen. When I called on Sunday, I was told that it was held up in transit and that I had no answer for why they were shipped together. I wanted to know why I had to have an item replaced every time. I didn't get a response. So called on Monday. I got a rude rep who kept asking if I was calling about the vanilla even after I told her why I was calling. Since they shoved them together, I'm calling about 2 items. She called logistics after getting annoyed with me. I want to speak to a manager because I don't know when it's going to happen. She didn't want to have to tell me or get a manager because she didn't want to ask them about the lost package. I had to go through it all over again after calling back. I got a new bottle with an actual lid after a manager apologized and sent me one. She gave me a $10 credit and gave me a refund because the tips were not in stock until the 20th, and she said she found a set for 11.93. I got off the phone and followed her link and didn't get any of the tips I wanted. I spent $12 on 2 tips, but they were advertised at $3 for 3, even though I couldn't find them anywhere. We will see if I get my other 2 tips by friday since the whole order was a mess.

11. Watkins Natural Extract Imitation Caramel

Watkins Natural Extract Imitation Caramel

Only the finest ingredients were used. Excellent results in baking. Superior results are guaranteed by concentrated flavor.

Brand: Watkins

👤This made our beer taste great.

👤This has been added to my cofeee. It doesn't taste like caramel. Overpriced. Disappointing.

👤I love it! The string caramel flavor is good. If you start with 1/2 of a cup, you will be on your way to using a full cup. I've used it in a lot of things. I couldn't find it in some stores. When I shipped there, I used d to find it in Walmart. It was very expensive on Amazon. Almost $7. It's under $2 at Walmart. I like using other watkins extracts. caramel is my favorite. Yes. I spent it. Highly recommend all Watkins extracts.

👤I brew my coffee with a few drops of caramel flavor. It was delicious!

👤I used it in a recipe I bought. I don't like the flavor.

👤This was used to make butter beer.

👤Watkins extracts never let me down.

👤Love scent. Apple cake recipes are great.


What is the best product for watkins clear vanilla extract for baking?

Watkins clear vanilla extract for baking products from Watkins. In this article about watkins clear vanilla extract for baking you can see why people choose the product. [brand2] and [brand3] are also good brands to look for when you are finding watkins clear vanilla extract for baking.

You May Like

Share Your Story

Your name:
Choose product to comment:
Write your review:
By submitting this review, you are agree that:
  • Your review is based on fact, honest, polite and not harmful to anyone or any brands.
  • We have full right to show or not-to-show your review after moderation.
  • No spamm please :)
We might earn comission for your shopping via our links, it doesn't cost you extra. This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to